Why Some Women Date Total Jerks
by Paul ~ August 19th, 2011 at 4:39 pmHe talks down to her, puts her down in front of others, touches her inappropriately or even violently, lies to her, rarely does anything nice to her, demands things from her (especially sexually), and has cheated on her. And yet she still sticks with him. Everyone thinks “wow, she can do so much better”. But for some reason, she doesn’t think so. Why is she with that jerk?
I’ve pondered this question since 5th grade, when my friend Chris and I would sit on the playground and ponder the ways of girls and express our confusion. After going through life seeing this again and again, I think I’ve figured it out. Based on my experience, here’s why it happens.
1) She Feels Unlovely, Undesirable, Unclean, and/or Unwanted (despite all indicators contrary!)
This is how she sees herself, deep down. There could be various reasons. Sexual Abuse is a common one (1 in 4 women have been sexually abused), including in dating relationships especially in high school or college. This is especially harmful when the sexual abuse does have an aspect of physical pleasure (because sex does feel good), so she thinks that it must be okay if she’s enjoying it (which it most assuredly is NOT okay). Other reasons include having an emotionally distant or abusive parent, having drug or alcohol addicted parents, or having no father in the house. It could also be from growing up with something that she felt was “unattractive” (real or imagined), like being too tall, too tom-boyish, too “overweight” (by Cosmo’s standards), having bad acne, having a lisp, or any of the various physical things that everyone struggles with at some point. She could be the most physically attractive girl (by worldly standards) and yet feels totally undesirable.
Ah, if she only knew the truth in how she is truly beloved! (Which I’ll address later)
2) He talks her up and then down
The Jerk knows she feels like this. He takes full advantage of this. Because hey, he wants to get laid. So the Jerk plays a smooth game of keeping her on her roller-coaster of feelings. He starts off with lots of smooth talk that makes her feel desired and loved. But soon he shifts that and (revealing his true heart) he treats her as unlovely, undesirable, unclean, and unwanted. He puts her down and plays mind-games to make her continue in this state. He might play hard to get, not calling her or leaving unexpectedly. He fights with her a lot. We he’s pushes her a bit too far, he will then again whisper his sweet nothings. When she’s finally had enough and she tries to leave him, he’ll either say that she’s lucky to have him or he’ll feign like he really does love her (often with tears) and make some petty attempt to make her feel vaguely loved (maybe even buying her an engagement ring, but please please PLEASE don’t fall for that!).
3) She feels like she has to earn his love
In this state, she now CRAVES to be loved (she was indeed created to be loved, which I’ll get to in a minute). But since she feels unlovely, she feel like she has to do something in order to earn that love. The Jerk then uses this to make her do things for him, like wash his clothes, clean up after him, give him money (especially if he’s unemployed), or perform demeaning sexual favors. He shows her some love and affection, but only enough to keep fueling that craving of hers and ensuring she keeps working hard to please him.
This is a “legalistic” relationship, where she is seeking to earn his love and he is using that to dominate her. This is an unhealthy relationship. This is a result of the fall. God predicted this would happen, as He said to Eve:
“Your desire shall be for your husband,
and he shall rule over you.” (Genesis 3:16b)
This is what I want to tell her:
You are lovely. You are desirable. You are clean, You are wanted. In Jesus Christ.
God created you and made you beautiful and lovely and you continue to be a lovely creation in His eyes.
God made you to love Him and He greatly desires to be in relationship with you. God showed this by sending His son Jesus Christ.
Jesus Christ cleans away all your dirty sins and secrets. He rights all your wrongs. He can make you clean and new.
Jesus Christ died for you to bring you to God to be loved eternally by Him. He was willing to give His life to have you. That is how much you are wanted.
YOU DO NOT HAVE TO DO ANYTHING to earn this love. God offers it freely to you in Jesus Christ. You just need to have faith that you are so wonderfully loved!
Dump that dude. God has so much better for you.
Here’s TWO wonderful music videos that perfectly capture this, one by Johnny Diaz and one by Tenth Avenue North:




